Vedadots
Q4041/80Q42
Q41·CSAT · Prelims 2023

Vernal window passage - Assumptions

Reading Comp.Environment / Ecology passageRC - Assumption validationMedium

Question

With reference to the above passage, the following assumptions have been made:

1Global warming is causing spring to come early and for longer durations.
2Early spring and longer period of spring is not good for bird populations.

Options

a

1 only

b

2 only

c

Both 1 and 2

d

Neither 1 nor 2

Answer

Explanation

Evaluate both assumptions carefully against the text [cite: 2714, 2715]:

Assumption 1 specifies "Global warming" causes early, elongated springs. However, the passage only mentions "warmer winters with less snow" as a localized observation, without identifying macro-level global warming as the explicit driver.

Assumption 2 generalizes that early/longer spring is "not good for bird populations". The text states that early ice-melt causes birds not to return, which delays or lengthens ecological events. It highlights a disruption in the ecological timetable, but it does not evaluate the overall health, survival, or well-being of the bird population itself. Therefore, neither assumption can be validated[cite: 3670, 3671].

Avoid validating assumptions that transform an ecological timeline shift or disruption described in the text into a definitive value judgment about species survival.

Answer: (d).

Question details

Year

2023

Paper

CSAT

Question

Q41

Section

Reading Comprehension

Sub-topic

Environment / Ecology passage

Type

RC - Assumption validation

Difficulty

Medium

Source hint

Passage-based comprehension

Same sub-topic — other years

Environment / Ecology passage has appeared in multiple CSAT papers:

See all questions on Environment / Ecology passage

Browse every tagged question across all years

Explore →